Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

I don't get your time thing there. Fantasy and 40k have completly different time-zones. So IF (and that's a big one, altough I like the idea) Sigmar was the missing Primarch, then the current fantasy universe would still be a few centuries (probably even millenias) before the age of apostaphy.

How does Valten fit inot all this?

and about the lost Legions...what about the Legion of the Damned?

and about the lost Legions...what about the Legion of the Damned

I believe the Legion of the Damned was originally the Fire Hawks, part of the "cursed" founding.

valten is the other missing primarch

Valten fell from the sky?

so two Primarchs fell on the same planet but the other one just landed 2500 years later? I doubt that.

but let's presume Sigmar is the first missing Primarch...what is his Legion and who is the other one?

if sigmar is A PRIMARCH then so is valten. cmon if one can land 37500 years late why cant the other land 2500 years later than the first.time flows differently in the immateriam

again, you assume that Warhammer Fanatsy year 2500 is the 40k year...well 40.000. the "old World" may be just a backwater planet cut off by a Warpstorm, but there's no reason to think the timeline's the same.

and, if Valten was the 2. missing Primarch, then why did ast so similar. using forgehammers to fight of beastman and stuff. most of the Primarchs are very different to another.

cos they were twins

and Magnus the red is Sanguinuis twin brother. I don't see any resemblence...

yeah magnus the "RED" and SANguinius, both red. hence twins. its just as viable as sigmar is a primarch. actualyy Superman is the other lost primarch. fell from the sky, had superhuman powers.shoots warp energy from his eyes, can fly. hge was the ultimate primarch.

Superman as the template for primarchs...why didn't I realize that before?  Figures that GW wouldn't be original in anything.  Fell from the skies, adopted, superhuman feats at a young age, special powers - the only thing that is atypical is that he never tried to run the planet, or a significant portion of it, merely acted as its protector.

I dig Sigmar being a Primarch, and his 'death' could be that he was found and spirited away.  Who he was found by is anyones guess...  Chaos could have found him and destroyed him or turned them to their own devices, the Emperor could have found him, and then he was lost in the warp.

I also think folks confuse the timeline of the Old World and of Terra.  What's 2500 in OWT, could easily be 38K in Terra Time.